|
Appendix - Surface Curvature Effects on Thermal
Output
Frank F. Hines (
Proceedings, Western Regional Strain Gage
Committee
, Nov. 9, 1960, pp. 39-44.) has demonstrated that
when a strain gage is installed on a sharply curved
surface the thermal output manifested by such an
installation is different than for the same gage
mounted on a flat surface. The curvature-induced
change in thermal output, referred to here as the
incremental thermal output, is due to the fact that
the strain-sensitive grid of the gage is above the
surface of the test member by the thickness of the
gage backing and adhesive layer. It can be shown that
under these conditions a temperature change causes a
different strain in the grid than would occur with
the grid bonded to a plane surface. The result is an
altered thermal output from the data provided in the
gage package.
The curvature-induced incremental thermal output
is a second-order effect which can ordinarily be
ignored; but it can become significant when the
radius of curvature is very small. As a rule of
thumb, the incremental thermal output can be
neglected when the radius of curvature is 0.5 in (13
mm) or greater. With smaller radii, correction may be
necessary, depending upon the required
strain-measurement accuracy.
Employing the same basic approach and
approximations used by Hines in his derivation, but
generalizing the treatment to allow for any
combination of adhesive and backing properties, an
expression for estimating the incremental thermal
output can be written as follows:
Eq.(504.A-1)
where, in consistent units,
= curvature-induced incremental thermal output.
= radius of curvature of test surface at gage site.
= average Poisson's ratio of adhesive and
backing.
= adhesive and backing thickness, respectively.
= thermal expansion coefficients of adhesive and
backing, respectively.
= thermal expansion coefficient of substrate
(specimen material).
= temperature change from reference
temperature.
Approximate values for the adhesive and backing
parameters in Eq. (504.A-1) are given in Table A-1
for representative Micro-Measurements adhesives and
gage series. The sign of the incremental thermal
output is obtained from Eq. (504.A-1) when the signs
of
and
are properly accounted for - that is, an increase in
temperature from the reference temperature is taken
as positive, and a decrease negative; and
correspondingly, a convex curvature is positive,
while a concave curvature is negative. The calculated
result from Eq.(504.A-1) is then added algebraically
to the thermal output data supplied in the gage
package to give the curvature-corrected thermal
output for use in making thermal output corrections
as shown in this publication.
Table A-1
Adhesive and Backing Parameters for Use with Eq.
504.A-1
|
Adhesive
|
, in (mm)
|
, ppm/° F (ppm/° C)
|
| M-Bond 200 |
0.0006 (0.015) |
45 (81) |
| M-Bond AE-10/15 |
0.0010 (0.025) |
45 (81) |
| M-Bond 600/610 |
0.0002 (0.005) |
45 (81) |
|
|
|
|
Gage Series (Backings)
|
, in (mm)
|
, ppm/° F (ppm/° C)
|
| EA, CEA, EP, ED |
0.0012 (0.030) |
50 (90) |
| SA, SK, SD, S2K |
0.0010 (0.025) |
10 (18) |
| WA, WK, WD |
0.0015 (0.038) |
10 (18) |

= 0.35 for all combinations.
Because the adhesive and backing parameters given in
Table A-1 are approximate, and are affected by gage
installation technique and other variables, the
curvature correction defined by Eq.(504.A-1) is
limited in accuracy. When the surface curvature is
severe enough so that the curvature induced
incremental thermal output may be important, the
actual thermal output should be measured as described
earlier
. In other words, the strain gage should be bonded to
the test part as for strain measurement, a
thermocouple or resistance temperature sensor should
be installed adjacent to the gage, and the test part
then subjected to test temperatures (while free of
mechanical and thermal stresses) to record the
"true" thermal output.
As an aid in judging the approximate magnitude of
the curvature-induced thermal output, Eq. (504.A-1)
has been evaluated for several representative
combinations of Micro-Measurements adhesives and gage
series. Parameters from Table A-1 were substituted
into the equation, along with
= 6.0E-6 (assuming a steel test material), and the
results plotted in Fig. A-1. Note, in the figure,
that the ordinate gives the incremental thermal
output per unit of temperature change from the
initial reference temperature - that is,
/
.
Fig. A-1 - Equation (A-1) evaluated and plotted
for various standard Micro-Measurements strain gage
backing materials when bonded to a steel
substrate.
|